25 January 2010 @ 03:15 am
The Projection Booth Scene: An analyzation, part 2.  
Tarantino has stated that the projection booth scene is both romantic and a consummation of Shosanna and Fredrick's relationship. After going over this previously in discussions with [livejournal.com profile] pellnell and[livejournal.com profile] piecesofalice (I love your brilliant minds), I decided to wrangle up screencaps and have at it. I've retread some previous ground, but it was necessary for the analyzation. Lots of screencaps along with key quotes from Tarantino and my rambling. Again, I'll let the actors' performances do most of the talking.







Now what intrigues me is how the publicity still of Shosanna from the projection booth is of her appearing confident and self-assured:



When the reality is entirely different. It's a split-second decision, but she's grimacing and apprehensive:



As discussed between Tarantino and Kim Morgan from this incredible interview:

"And, in that pivotal moment, she doesn’t want to shoot him. She doesn’t want to kill him."


Despite all that Shosanna and Fredrick have been through, they are still a couple of innocents. Her panic and realization of what she has done is simply moving, as Shosanna sees the contrast between the lavish, over-the-top Goebbels production of Fredrick, and the dying, damaged young man in the projection booth:



Her immediate guilt over acknowledging what she has done and what she feels is stunning, as she is drawn to both the film and Fredrick:



As the script states: "The Face on the silver screen, breaks the young girl's
heart..."



Shosanna hesitates briefly, as she knows what she must do:





Red is the color of passion, power, and love, whereas white is the color of purity and innocence. Dressed in red, Shosanna holds dominance over Fredrick; by using the suggestion of sex, she becomes the sexual aggressor. By shooting Fredrick, Shosanna initiates their consummation. And to go one step further, it can even be said that by using her pistol, a phallic object, Shosanna first penetrates him; as far as sexual positions are concerned, she is on top.

Pistol still in hand, she goes to Fredrick, who is bathed in white light. We see here, in Shosanna, the vulnerability and sensitive part of herself which she has kept private and guarded until now, until meeting Fredrick. Setting the pistol aside, she kneels beside him. The way Shosanna looks Fredrick over, the way she gently touches him, the tenderness she shows him is breath-taking:



Turning him over, to comfort him, Fredrick fires back, reciprocating the act and penetrating her. Shosanna started out on top, and now, the positions have been switched. In their act of consummation, they are both equals. The spray of blood - again, if you want to go that far - could be seen as ejaculate. Interestingly, the blood spray even spreads to between Fredrick's legs.



As her body falls to the floor, you can see Fredrick onscreen behind Shosanna. Getting into more phallic and sexual imagery, he is re-loading his rifle:



Watching her fall, you can see Fredrick's own agony and heartbreak:



Her facial expressions as she falls and writhes on the floor are quite sensual:



There is no hate, no malice in this scene. Fredrick is lovesick and grief-stricken more than anything, which is evident in his facial expression and how his hand violently shakes as he holds back on pulling the trigger once more. Even though Fredrick does so, it is an act of mercy, an act of love:



To get into the sexual connotations, Fredrick's final shot could be viewed as the final thrust to bring Shosanna to climax; it's all in her facial expressions and the way she cries out. And paying attention to them both, their expressions are as if they're in the throes of orgasm (Fredrick's luger is even held at crotch level):





Together, Shosanna and Fredrick die as Ennio Morricone's love theme, Un Amico plays.

It is here that it must also be noted, as Quentin's lovers lay together on the floor of the projection booth, that Shosanna is barefoot.

The sight of women's bare feet is something that any fan (or, even, casual viewer) of the films of Quentin Tarantino is well-acquainted with. However, here, the presence of bare feet extends far past the whims of a foot fetishist - indeed, there is even meaning to be found here.

Though far more obvious in the films Death Proof and Kill Bill, Tarantino utilizes women's bare feet as most other directors utilize nudity. Usually in moments of vulnerability and sexuality, bare feet are shown in place of a nude body, and as proven by this scene, they are no less effective than that of the nudity present in a traditional love scene.

Shosanna ends her scenes in the film as she did at the opening of Inglourious Basterds: bare foot.

But, whereas in the beginning, she is vulnerably in fear for her life, here, she is vulnerable in a manner like that of a tentative young lover and her paramour. It is present in her approach of Fredrick as he lays on the floor and in the absolute compassion she displays for him - truly, in the projection booth, Shosanna's barefoot state is entirely sexual.

Just as bullets and the blood represent their lovemaking, Shosanna's bare feet represents her own nudity with Fredrick. To add further to its importance, Fredrick is the only man she is shown barefoot with; Shosanna is willingly open, exposed, and laid-bare for Fredrick and Fredrick alone.



As discussed with [livejournal.com profile] pellnell, death and sex are when all is laid bare and when one is at their most vulnerable. Shosanna and Fredrick have allowed only each other to see those parts of themselves; by giving of themselves fully to one another, their feelings for each other were fully realized. The tragedy lies in the fact that due to the circumstance they are trapped in, Shosanna and Fredrick could not be together in life; however, the beauty is that they have in death what life denied them, to die by the hand of the one who loved them, uniting them for eternity. Even as chaos rages around them and Le Gamaar goes up in flames, Shosanna and Fredrick are as they should have always been: together, at peace, protected, and completely separate from the hideous reality that surrounds them. They remain innocents until their last breath; the war had taken everything from Shosanna just as it gave Fredrick everything, leaving both of them broken.

The deaths of Shosanna and Fredrick are an interesting contrast to the death of Bridget von Hammersmark at the hands of Hans Landa. Whereas Shosanna's and Fredrick's deaths were a consummation of their relationship and feelings for each other, Bridget's was a violation, a rape; aggressive and extremely personal, she did not return Landa's violent affections and opposed him every second of it.



Shosanna and Fredrick are two halves which form a whole. One way or another, it was their fate to be together, and nothing could get in the way of that, nor could anything come between them.

 
 
où: HOME.
se sentent: awake
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 26th, 2010 08:46 am (UTC)
I've tried but I can't find a decent dl with subtitles! I DO NOT SPEAK GERMAN INTERNET FOLKS.

Oh haha but I'll probably love August because I have the tendency to love characters who are MAJOR DOUCHES. And you know... it's August ♥
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: You're so fragile tonight[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on January 28th, 2010 03:10 am (UTC)
I'm downloading Tattoo for nude August and the lead actress is hot and I'm sure it has no subtitles, either. But then, Love In Thoughts is a beautiful film and the dialogue is important.

August's character is just so desperate and driven by his obsessive love for Thure's character, Hans, that he ends up hurting everyone, though it's not entirely intentional. Also, it's the best he's ever looked; he's just so damned beautiful as Gunther it's ridiculous (gaunt and depressed works for him). I've talked with [livejournal.com profile] piecesofalice about how August, as he was as Gunther, would have made an interesting Fredrick. He'd play the part far more damaged and world-weary, I think, and his Fredrick wouldn't have had the naivete and innocence of Daniel's, but it'd be interesting.

I've loved August since Love the Hard Way from 2001. It was his first English-speaking role and his accent is overwhelming and the film sucks, but he wears suits and nail polish and eyeliner:



He's exactly what the high school me wanted in a man.
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 29th, 2010 09:12 am (UTC)
There are like 6 August movies on [livejournal.com profile] ifilm_exchange but I haven't dl them because I need to delete stuff on my laptop. I think it's time I say goodbye to Glee and Misfits. I need to make space for Skins too.

Interesting indeed. I'll make a better comment after I see the movie!

WHAT IS THIS I CAN'T EVEN- I MUST WATCH THIS!
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: A moment out of time[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on January 29th, 2010 09:40 am (UTC)
MAKE ROOM FOR AUGUST BECAUSE HE'S IMPORTANT. I love him so much because he's like Brad Dourif, Christopher Walken, and Crispin Glover; so many of his films can be total lolz (yes, I am eloquent), but he gives every role everything he's got.

Love In Thoughts may very well be August's best work and I'd love to see him play more characters like Gunther.

ADRIEN BRODY AND THIS LADY WITH OBNOXIOUS IMPLANTS ARE THE LEADS AND THEY'RE THE DUMBEST COUPLE WHO ARE RUINING EACH OTHER'S LIVES BUT IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE A LOVE STORY. THEN AUGUST IS ALL, "YOU CAN STAY IN MY APARTMENT, WOMAN WHO IS PISSING AWAY HER FUTURE WITH A LOSER."
SO THEN SHE BECOMES A PROSTITUTE AND ADRIEN BLAMES IT ON AUGUST AND POINTS A GUN AT HIM AND AUGUST STARTS CRYING. He was quite good, so I have to revisit it for August and relive my teen years.
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 12:56 am (UTC)
Christopher Walken can't do wrong in my eyes since he did the Weapon of Choice video. HE'S MY PERSONAL HERO.

AAARGH TRYING TO FIND A GOOD DL LINK AS WE SPEAK.

ADRIEN BRODY IS IN THIS???? BE STILL MY HEART. I nee to have an epic August Diehl movie marathon before my semester starts!
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: Acting on your best behaviour[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 01:19 am (UTC)
THAT IS AWESOME. I LOVE WALKEN AND I HAVE SUCH LUST FOR HIM IN THE '70S - '80S.

I HOPE YOU FIND ONE BECAUSE IT'S SO GOOD AND DEPRESSING AND GORGEOUS. ALSO:


When I'm not marveling at what an idiot his character is, I then wonder how Adrien and August's characters even became friends in the first place.
AUGUST, YOU WEAR SUITS AND EYE-LINER YET YOU WORK IN A FANCY HOTEL AND YOU MAKE SNARKY COMMENTS AT EVERYONE AND YOU HAVE A DR. WHO SCARF. WHAT'S GOING ON HERE?
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 02:21 am (UTC)
I WON'T BE IN PEACE WITH MYSELF UNTIL I WATCH THIS MOVIE!!!!

AHAHAHAHAHA! I THINK I'M GOING TO LOVE AUGUST IN THIS MOVIE.
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: Don't be a good neighbor to her[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 02:53 am (UTC)


LOVE THE HARD WAY WILL GIVE YOU MANY LOLZ. I LOVE IT WHEN SOME BAD SHIT GOES DOWN AND AUGUST IS CLEARLY SMIRKING.

ALSO, HERE'S AUGUST ON TOP OF ELLEN PAGE FROM MOUTH TO MOUTH: http://images.celebritymoviearchive.com/members/thumbs/e/EllenPage@MouthtoMouth-1-CMA.jpg
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 07:33 am (UTC)
GOOD CAUSE I LOVE LOLZ. LOLZ ARE AWESOME.

ELLEN PAGE YOU LUCKY BITCH.

I've forgotten ask you, why haven't we friended each other? You're pretty awesome and I'd like to have you on my friends list :D
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: GTFO MARCEL[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 02:01 pm (UTC)
GOOD. HIS SCRUNCH-FACED CRYING IS BOTH LULZY AND ADORABLE. ALSO, ADRIEN IS DRESSED LIKE A POLICE OFFICER.

ELLEN PAGE GETS SCARED, THOUGH, AND KICKS HIM OFF OF HER. HIS CHARACTER'S NAME IS TIGER. AUGUST IS PLAYING A MAN NAMED TIGER AND HE'S VIOLATING ELLEN PAGE. IT'S SORT OF MIND-BOGGLING. IT'S NOT A BAD FILM, YET SOMEONE HANDED HIM A SCRIPT WITH ALL OF THESE DETAILS AND HE DECIDED, "WHY YES, I WILL PLAY A MAN NAMED TIGER."

I have no clue, but I shall remedy the situation.

YES I AM AWESOME, THANKS FOR NOTICING.
[identity profile] delarges.livejournal.com on January 30th, 2010 09:39 pm (UTC)
THIS MOVIE KEEPS GETTING BETTER BY THE SECOND.

OH I SEE! BUT MY, THAT'S QUITE AN USEFUL NAME. AND IF YOU ASK ME I BET THAT'S HE'S A TIGER DURING SEXYTIMES.

Good, good. Glad you handled the situation.