25 January 2010 @ 03:15 am
The Projection Booth Scene: An analyzation, part 2.  
Tarantino has stated that the projection booth scene is both romantic and a consummation of Shosanna and Fredrick's relationship. After going over this previously in discussions with [livejournal.com profile] pellnell and[livejournal.com profile] piecesofalice (I love your brilliant minds), I decided to wrangle up screencaps and have at it. I've retread some previous ground, but it was necessary for the analyzation. Lots of screencaps along with key quotes from Tarantino and my rambling. Again, I'll let the actors' performances do most of the talking.







Now what intrigues me is how the publicity still of Shosanna from the projection booth is of her appearing confident and self-assured:



When the reality is entirely different. It's a split-second decision, but she's grimacing and apprehensive:



As discussed between Tarantino and Kim Morgan from this incredible interview:

"And, in that pivotal moment, she doesn’t want to shoot him. She doesn’t want to kill him."


Despite all that Shosanna and Fredrick have been through, they are still a couple of innocents. Her panic and realization of what she has done is simply moving, as Shosanna sees the contrast between the lavish, over-the-top Goebbels production of Fredrick, and the dying, damaged young man in the projection booth:



Her immediate guilt over acknowledging what she has done and what she feels is stunning, as she is drawn to both the film and Fredrick:



As the script states: "The Face on the silver screen, breaks the young girl's
heart..."



Shosanna hesitates briefly, as she knows what she must do:





Red is the color of passion, power, and love, whereas white is the color of purity and innocence. Dressed in red, Shosanna holds dominance over Fredrick; by using the suggestion of sex, she becomes the sexual aggressor. By shooting Fredrick, Shosanna initiates their consummation. And to go one step further, it can even be said that by using her pistol, a phallic object, Shosanna first penetrates him; as far as sexual positions are concerned, she is on top.

Pistol still in hand, she goes to Fredrick, who is bathed in white light. We see here, in Shosanna, the vulnerability and sensitive part of herself which she has kept private and guarded until now, until meeting Fredrick. Setting the pistol aside, she kneels beside him. The way Shosanna looks Fredrick over, the way she gently touches him, the tenderness she shows him is breath-taking:



Turning him over, to comfort him, Fredrick fires back, reciprocating the act and penetrating her. Shosanna started out on top, and now, the positions have been switched. In their act of consummation, they are both equals. The spray of blood - again, if you want to go that far - could be seen as ejaculate. Interestingly, the blood spray even spreads to between Fredrick's legs.



As her body falls to the floor, you can see Fredrick onscreen behind Shosanna. Getting into more phallic and sexual imagery, he is re-loading his rifle:



Watching her fall, you can see Fredrick's own agony and heartbreak:



Her facial expressions as she falls and writhes on the floor are quite sensual:



There is no hate, no malice in this scene. Fredrick is lovesick and grief-stricken more than anything, which is evident in his facial expression and how his hand violently shakes as he holds back on pulling the trigger once more. Even though Fredrick does so, it is an act of mercy, an act of love:



To get into the sexual connotations, Fredrick's final shot could be viewed as the final thrust to bring Shosanna to climax; it's all in her facial expressions and the way she cries out. And paying attention to them both, their expressions are as if they're in the throes of orgasm (Fredrick's luger is even held at crotch level):





Together, Shosanna and Fredrick die as Ennio Morricone's love theme, Un Amico plays.

It is here that it must also be noted, as Quentin's lovers lay together on the floor of the projection booth, that Shosanna is barefoot.

The sight of women's bare feet is something that any fan (or, even, casual viewer) of the films of Quentin Tarantino is well-acquainted with. However, here, the presence of bare feet extends far past the whims of a foot fetishist - indeed, there is even meaning to be found here.

Though far more obvious in the films Death Proof and Kill Bill, Tarantino utilizes women's bare feet as most other directors utilize nudity. Usually in moments of vulnerability and sexuality, bare feet are shown in place of a nude body, and as proven by this scene, they are no less effective than that of the nudity present in a traditional love scene.

Shosanna ends her scenes in the film as she did at the opening of Inglourious Basterds: bare foot.

But, whereas in the beginning, she is vulnerably in fear for her life, here, she is vulnerable in a manner like that of a tentative young lover and her paramour. It is present in her approach of Fredrick as he lays on the floor and in the absolute compassion she displays for him - truly, in the projection booth, Shosanna's barefoot state is entirely sexual.

Just as bullets and the blood represent their lovemaking, Shosanna's bare feet represents her own nudity with Fredrick. To add further to its importance, Fredrick is the only man she is shown barefoot with; Shosanna is willingly open, exposed, and laid-bare for Fredrick and Fredrick alone.



As discussed with [livejournal.com profile] pellnell, death and sex are when all is laid bare and when one is at their most vulnerable. Shosanna and Fredrick have allowed only each other to see those parts of themselves; by giving of themselves fully to one another, their feelings for each other were fully realized. The tragedy lies in the fact that due to the circumstance they are trapped in, Shosanna and Fredrick could not be together in life; however, the beauty is that they have in death what life denied them, to die by the hand of the one who loved them, uniting them for eternity. Even as chaos rages around them and Le Gamaar goes up in flames, Shosanna and Fredrick are as they should have always been: together, at peace, protected, and completely separate from the hideous reality that surrounds them. They remain innocents until their last breath; the war had taken everything from Shosanna just as it gave Fredrick everything, leaving both of them broken.

The deaths of Shosanna and Fredrick are an interesting contrast to the death of Bridget von Hammersmark at the hands of Hans Landa. Whereas Shosanna's and Fredrick's deaths were a consummation of their relationship and feelings for each other, Bridget's was a violation, a rape; aggressive and extremely personal, she did not return Landa's violent affections and opposed him every second of it.



Shosanna and Fredrick are two halves which form a whole. One way or another, it was their fate to be together, and nothing could get in the way of that, nor could anything come between them.

 
 
où: HOME.
se sentent: awake
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] nickytheapache.livejournal.com on March 21st, 2010 05:59 am (UTC)
I'm so very glad they inspired you! It's obvious how close you are to these characters - it comes out beautifully in both your fanfiction and analysis. It's incredible.

It's only brilliant people such as yourself who notice such things. Quentin would be so proud. :)

Once again, I'm so glad you were able to find a connection with them!

Hopefully I can be as insightful as you one day. I'm just shy of 16, and I am wiser than some, but wisdom is what I long for!
And maybe Daniel Bruhl.
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: Judgement made can never bend[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on March 22nd, 2010 04:20 am (UTC)
They both have such relatable qualities and are the most human of the characters in IB (at least for me), and they're both two halves that form a whole when together, so I'm a bit protective of them; I'm glad that the care and consideration I put into writing for them comes through.

It takes an eye for detail, is all. I would love, however, to completely talk Quentin's ear off ♥

Hopefully I can be as insightful as you one day. I'm just shy of 16, and I am wiser than some, but wisdom is what I long for!
Oh, I think you're on your way there. There's beauty and meaning to be found nearly everywhere, in nearly everything, which be both enlightening and frustrating.

And maybe Daniel Bruhl.
We all could use a Daniel in our lives.
[identity profile] nickytheapache.livejournal.com on March 22nd, 2010 04:32 am (UTC)
Oh, it really, really does. And you have every right to be protective of them! Afterall, you've opened up the eyes of many (I'm assuming) when it comes to their relationship. In my case, at least! Like I said, I had the gist of the situation when I thought about it, but your analysis was SO helpful.

I'm too scared to ever write a fanfic for them, because I don't want to ruin them. I'll leave the fanfiction to you, since you have a knack at nailing it every time (from what I've read so far!)

Oh, I'm sure Quentin would adore you. :)

Hehe, I hope I'm on my way there! And that is so very true. I am just beginning to obsess over finding beauty and meaning in all things, and I'm enjoying it immensely. :)

HAHA, we really could.
Or.. you and I could just share him...
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: As I'm breaking in two electric blue[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on March 23rd, 2010 06:23 am (UTC)
I'm glad to have been able to help you along, as I adore them to such a degree that I have to put my perspective out there, especially since their significance to one another is far too overlooked. I also greatly enjoy being able to have such lively conversations with others about them, as it has led to me to further insights and a whole new appreciation for Tarantino, Melanie, and Daniel.

I was terrified of writing fanfiction for them, too, especially since I hadn't written fiction in so long, let alone having never written fanfiction before. They can be a bit of a challenge, and they do take a level of restraint; I have to make certain to stay as true to the characters as possible, though I there are times when I want them to ride off into the sunset on a unicorn. If you ever do write them, though, I'd love to read it!

Oh, I'm sure Quentin would adore you. :)
He and I could be BFF and giggle about Italian schlock films from the '70s ♥

I am just beginning to obsess over finding beauty and meaning in all things, and I'm enjoying it immensely. :)
Wonderful! It gives an interesting perspective on everyday life, and as Ferris Bueller advised, it allows for you to slow down and look around.

Sharing is caring, or so they say. ♥
[identity profile] nickytheapache.livejournal.com on March 24th, 2010 04:10 am (UTC)
I think I will try out the whole quoting-in-replies thing. It is much neater and easier to read comments that way!

I also greatly enjoy being able to have such lively conversations with others about them, as it has led to me to further insights and a whole new appreciation for Tarantino, Melanie, and Daniel.
AMEN.

You do an excellent job at keeping them in character. Such care, such talent. Perhaps when I have a greater understanding of them - as in, EXPERT on Zoller/Dreyfus - I may write a fic! I will be sure to notify you, but I can't make any promises that they won't ride off into the sunset on a unicorn... Haha

You and Quentin would so be BFF. I wish that were so. You would totally have connections to Daniel and Melanie this way, and I'm sure you wouldn't mind shipping Dannyboy over to Canada every so often, wouldja?

Oh, Ferris. What a genius. My careless ex-stepbrother ruined my Ferris Bueller DVD, and I really need to get my hands on a new one. I miss that movie.

Sharing IS caring. ♥
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: Carried away[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on April 1st, 2010 03:21 am (UTC)
You do an excellent job at keeping them in character. Such care, such talent
Oh, goodness, thank you. I initially hoped for there to be other fans who would write them, but it was just me and few other LJ friends who loved them (openly, and in the beginning), and I knew I wasn't going to get the exact fic that I wanted. For other characters I love, such as Adrian Veidt, there have been plenty of other fans who have such a wonderful grasp on the character that their fic spoiled me for other fandoms. So basically, sometimes you just have to get the job done yourself. It took some time and lots of discussions before I felt comfortable enough to write them, and even longer after that to write more.

So when you do feel ready to write them, I'd love to read it! And I wouldn't mind unicorns, either.

I'm sure Daniel would love to visit Canada, as would Quentin.

My careless ex-stepbrother ruined my Ferris Bueller DVD, and I really need to get my hands on a new one. I miss that movie.
Aw. I once accidentally put in Death Proof when I already had my director's cut of Dawn of the Dead (Romero original, 1978) and the DVD player nearly ground it up.
[identity profile] nickytheapache.livejournal.com on April 3rd, 2010 02:03 am (UTC)
Perhaps there is still hope for me to one day write them, then! But until then, I am perfectly content with just reading your work! :D Haha, unicorns just may appear... There's no telling for sure.

Hehehe, yes, I'm sure they would both love to visit.

Eek! Hopefully your DVDs made it out alive, though!
http://suspiriorum.livejournal.com/: Lose yourself[identity profile] suspiriorum.livejournal.com on April 4th, 2010 05:47 am (UTC)
Of course there's still hope! You have such a wonderful grasp on them and I love that you're able to see past just the surface to how they really are and how important they are to each other's story arc. So, whenever you do feel comfortable enough to write them, I know you'll do them justice. I certainly wouldn't mind a unicorn, either ♥

You can then flail with all three of them over films (and of course, Shosanna/Fredrick)!

Death Proof was perfectly fine, and has been re-watched many times as it is the go-to film for my dad and I to watch together. I've not watched Dawn of the Dead yet to see if it survived. I'm sort of in denial over the possibility of it being ruined.
[identity profile] nickytheapache.livejournal.com on April 5th, 2010 06:58 am (UTC)
Of course there's still hope! You have such a wonderful grasp on them and I love that you're able to see past just the surface to how they really are and how important they are to each other's story arc. So, whenever you do feel comfortable enough to write them, I know you'll do them justice.
Aw, shucks!♥

I certainly wouldn't mind a unicorn, either ♥
I might just have to write a silly fic solely for unicorn idea.

YES, I WANT TO FLAIL WITH THEM! If I ever meet Daniel Bruhl, I will probably (by accident) end up blurting something out like, "I'LL BE YOUR REAL LIFE SHOSANNA, AND WE DON'T HAVE TO KILL EACHOTHER. WE CAN RUN AWAY...ON A UNICORN. PLEASE LOVE ME..." It would be disastrous, but definitely memorable for him...

I need to see Death Proof, actually! I'm glad if survived. ♥ Hopefully Dawn Of The Dead was as fortunate!